Apr 15

When I talk to PC using friends (or relatives) it can be somewhat of a difficult conversation trying to explain to them why I think switching is a good idea. Mainly it’s fear of the unknown. Most computer users regard their systems with the angst and awe typically reserved for the local shaman in prehistoric days. A computer uses ‘strange juju’ to get things done. One is better off not knowing too much about what’s under the hood or something might jump out and bite you. The same goes for cars, for electronic contraptions and various other things typically labelled with the rubric ‘technology.’ It’s a bit maddening, but then if everyone was good with computers there would be no need for consultants. So, hey, no problem.

With PC’s, the fear and angst is multiplied by the multiple barriers Windows puts in the way of understanding your computer. Merely navigating your file system is an exercise in futility. Where the bloody heck are my files located? In the name of making things easier, the file hierarchy has been totally obfuscated by the Start button plus windows shortcuts. I find it a bit maddening, but then I’m a Mac guy. Of course I do. It’s part of the package.

I use a PC almost daily now. You’d think I’d learn the ropes or become assimilated or something but nope, I’ve pretty much jumped the rabbit and gone straight to Linux. I’m actually getting work accomplished on Linux, something I usually find tedious and unproductive doing in Windows.

What’s the big deal? Why does the Mac make getting things done easier? In the main, the essence lies in the fact that a Mac is trying to get out of your way and let you get your work done. The menu bar at the top of the screen contains all the menu items you need whatever program you are in. And, they are ALWAYS in the same place. Want to cut or paste, or find a preference, or list your open windows. It’s always there in the menu bar.

Windows has this idea that every programmer can create their own interface, so each program tends to have its own set of quirks. If you want to see some truly wretched interfaces, open some Windows software. You won’t have to look long. There’s lots of great software in the Windows world but the interfaces don’t work all that well.

For an example, in the Mac operating system, you can pretty much cut and paste just about anything. In the Windows world, it’s kind of a crapshoot. Usually it works but then mysteriously not. Who knows why?

For the Mac user, the menu bar floats there always available, dependable, a touchstone of sanity and user friendliness than can always be depended upon. Likewise, dialog boxes that are clearly labeled with obvious choices. Have you ever found yourself in a Windows dialog with negative choices, as in ‘for something NOT to happen, click Okay.’ That’s not unusual.

Or how about wretchedly small type, or cramped windows filled with tiny buttons and no discernible way to access the program. It’s enough to make a user load Linux on their box.

Alas, we cannot simply turn our backs on Windows as it may morph into something even more ridiculous. Better to give it your full attention and ask for better.

More Mac plusses:

- truly elegant style and aesthetics applied to every aspect (well not every single aspect but good judgement prevails)
- simple design choices coupled with strong interface guidelines leads to a good user experience.
- while not as strong as in OS 9, OS X maintain a strong sense of spatial orientation in the Finder so that one retains a sense of moving in physical space in the Finder.
- the user interface has a strong guideline established to make the operating system comprehensible at the user level for beginners to advanced users
- design choices are replicated throughout the OS so that whether you are in a Quicktime movie, editing a Photoshop file, or checking your email, the same services and menubar choices are available leading to predictable outcomes
- Instead of feeling cobbled together by a committe, the OX feels like a work of art, very unified and comprehensive in its approach and an excellent interface between the user and the UNIX engine driving the hardware.
- Just plain fun to use, like eye candy.
Guess I’ll have to come up with some Mac complaints in my next blog.

Leave a Reply